Thoughts on mixing music or podcasts with work. And, more general ones regarding sound.
I used to do a lot more listening to music while working than occurs now. A lot more sound while working, really.
My first "real job" was dealing blackjack and other casino games on an American Indian reservation.
Casinos are noisy. There was always music playing on the gaming floor - some mix of early 2000s pop and "classics" - plus a cacophony of slot machines and people swearing at me while I took their money.
This didn't stop me from doing satisfactory work. Running table games is a simple job  - you know the mechanics of a given game, it's a fixed system, and you run it.
Next, I started getting into software development. The same level of noise from the casino wouldn't have been tolerable.
The insurance company where I started out, however, would play a Top 40s mix all day long throughout the building. So there was noise, sure. It's just the development work there wasn't challenging enough that sound would hinder me.
After that, I spent a long time at a defense contractor. Here they were doing what I'll call "real engineering work." Like, brainy stuff.
To this point, occasionally I'd have a challenging engineering problem to tackle. I found I'd need silence to help me achieve focus. It could be found if you came in nights or weekends to knock out the tough stuff
Silence was hard to come by during the day, though. This is when I'd listen to electronic music with minimal to no dialogue in it. If not that, then binaural beats or classical music. Or movie soundtracks.
Other times, I'd have unit testing to do or more menial development tasks.  This is when I could listen to normal music without issue. A 90s hip-hop station, maybe.
Fast-forward to now, I've experimented with podcast listening while doing more menial tasks. Retesting software vulnerabilities is a good example. Doesn't require too much thinking.
Certainly it can be more of a hindrance than music. It's constant dialogue about something you're interested in. But, if you're like me, you have more podcasts you'd like to listen to than you actually have time. By listening over work, I seem to derive some value. Not as much as a focused listen, though more than not listening at all.
You might compare it to a conversation going on in the room where you're working. You tune in and out.
All of this is leading towards the following table of conclusions.
|Brain power needed||Examples||Maximum noise before mental hindrance|
|Peak||Algorithms work; thinking through unclear trade-offs in different solutions||None / Silence via ear plugs or other noise cancellation|
|High||Typical software development||Classical; electronic with minimal to no dialogue; binaural beats|
|Average-High||Certain software testing||Most music|
|Average-Low||Doing most expense reports, "paperwork"||All music + "other distractions"|
But of course, everything's relative. From what music interrupts you to what your "average-high" and "average-low" mental performance looks like.
For many people, though, I suspect this is how things fall.
 Not to say it was an easy job. Most people get pissed at the dealers as if they're to blame for their losses. This wears on you, day in and day out.
 Side note: I don't think menial tasks in general will ever completely go away. Some stuff is prone to automation, sure, but a lot of one-off or two-off computer tasks would simply take more time to script and debug than to just do manually and get out of the way.
Join my mailing list
About once a month, you'll get an exclusive email catching you up with me and the blog. Feel free to write back too - it's great hearing from readers.